Voices » Bill Taylor » Four Reasons Most Startups Fail (And How Yours Can Succeed)
1:39 PM Friday July 18, 2008
Last winter, when we all thought the economy had really taken a nosedive, I made the case that bad times could be the best of times to start a company. Well, over the last eight months, economic conditions have gone from bad to worse--but the startup boom shows few signs of slowing down.
Want proof? Spend time with Paul Graham, who's spent the last three years helping young entrepreneurs launch the companies of their dreams. Graham and his cofounders run a cool outfit called Y Combinator, with operations in two hotbeds of entrepreneurship: Silicon Valley and Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Graham and his colleagues provide both seed funding and hands-on advice to startups. Y Combinator invests a little money (rarely more than $20,000) and takes a small equity stake (an average of 6 percent or so.) And it funds its companies in "batches." Every summer, entrepreneurs from around the world apply for the chance to spend three months in Cambridge. Graham and his colleagues help people refine their ideas, critique their prototypes, and teach them how to present to venture capitalists and angels--all of which leads to a "Demo Day" for potential investors. Every winter, the same immersion experience takes place in Mountain View, California. There are two Demo Days in the Valley, given the sheer number of eager venture capitalists.
This summer, Graham's got 60 founders, representing 22 companies, at work on their ideas. All told, Y Combinator has invested in 102 startups--including a bunch that have attracted lots of money and attention (Loopt, for example) or been acquired by big-time players (Reddit, for example). In other words, Graham has seen it all when it comes to startups (including starting and selling a company of his own back in the first Internet boom.)
So how would Paul Graham advise young entrepreneurs who want to be "practically radical" in their approach to startups? He offers a few simple (and proven) principles that determine which startups work and which fail:
First, he says, "make something people want." It sounds obvious, but young entrepreneurs often fall in love with what technology can do as opposed to what customers need. One of the questions on the application to Y Combinator makes the point well: "What are people forced to do now because what you plan to do doesn't exist yet?"
Second, entrepreneurs have to "be willing to let their ideas change." This sounds strange: Aren't great startups built around a great idea? Yes, but a great idea isn't always the original idea. Countless times during the Y Combinator experience, startups have made dramatic changes not just in strategies and tactics, but in the very essence of what they do. Amazingly, Graham told me, the founders of Reddit came to Y Combinator with a plan to help people order fast food on their cell phones. When everyone agreed it wasn't exactly a killer idea, the desperate search for a new idea led to the launch of their successful company.
Third, and this also sounds strange, Graham tells startups: "Don't worry too much about money." That's what's really different about this second wave of Web-enabled startups: It's become so cheap to buy equipment, reach customers, and generate buzz on the Web, that the power of investors and venture capitalists is on the wane. "It's so much easier to get the money you need than to make something great," he says. Or, as Graham points out, today, unlike back in the mid-90s, you've got the MBAs working for the technologists, rather than the other way around.
Finally, Graham urges his company founders to always "be benevolent" in terms of how they do business--to act in the long-term best interests of customers, as opposed to the short-term best interests of themselves. In other words, the most important rule for starting a company is the Golden Rule--or, in the updated version in Google's strategic bible, "Don't be evil."
Why is benevolence powerful? First, it keeps morale and energy high. In an age of constant disruption and realignment, employees want to be the "good guys" in their field--so it makes sense for companies to act that way.
Second, more than ever, successful companies require the active participation of customers, suppliers, and industry enthusiasts. "If you're benevolent," Graham says, "people will rally around you" with ideas, improvements, and word-of-mouth marketing.
Finally, benevolence helps founders to be more decisive. If you make every decision based on "doing whatever is best for your users," it's that much easier to make decisions.
The most important decision, of course, is starting a company in the first place. And once you do, be sure to use these two resources: Paul's must-see talk to a gathering of entrepreneurs at Stanford called Startup School, and his must read-essay "How to Start a Startup."
Here's hoping you decide to get started--and that you succeed.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.harvardbusiness.org/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1705
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Four Reasons Most Startups Fail (And How Yours Can Succeed):
1-2-3 of Innovation from Udayan's Blog - From The Other Site:
Do you have an innovative idea worth pursuing?
“Innovation is work” – Peter Drucker in Innovation and Entrepreneurship
Why do you want to pursue your idea? Do you want to make money through your creation? Do you want to see your creation getting ... More
Posting Guidelines
We hope the conversations that take place on HarvardBusiness.org will be energetic, constructive, free-wheeling, and provocative. To make sure we all stay on-topic, all posts will be reviewed by our editors and may be edited for clarity, length, and relevance.
We ask that you adhere to the following guidelines.

William C. Taylor is an agenda-setting writer, speaker, and entrepreneur. His new project, Practically Radical, chronicles the radical shifts transforming business and the practical steps that will determine who wins. His most recent book,Mavericks at Work, has been a New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and BusinessWeek bestseller. As cofounder of Fast Company, he launched a magazine that earned a passionate following around the world. He is an adjunct lecturer at Babson College and a former associate editor of Harvard Business Review.
To learn more about Practically Radical, download a preview here.
ADVERTISEMENT
Michael Jackson and the Zombieconomy Umair Haque
How Michael Jackson Became a Brand Icon John Quelch
Debunking Social Media Myths David Armano
A Good Way to Change a Corporate Culture Peter Bregman
Great Communicators Are Great Explainers John Baldoni
Debunking Social Media Myths David Armano
Michael Jackson and the Zombieconomy Umair Haque
How Michael Jackson Became a Brand Icon John Quelch
How to Identify Your Employees' Hidden Talents Steven DeMaio
Why Microsoft Had to Destroy Word Peter Merholz
This simulation will help you learn how to craft conversations that are fact based, minimize defensiveness, and draw out the best thinking from everyone involved.
In many organizations, marketing exists far from the executive suite and the boardroom. Learn how to improve the link between high level corporate strategy and the marketing function.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comments
This sounds a lot like the LIFTr.com group.
- Posted by Aaron
July 21, 2008 4:41 PM
have an idea that has gotten full marks as per this criteria.
will definatly create such a seed funding venture in nairobi kenya
- Posted by zack
July 23, 2008 6:17 AM
Bill,
I took the plunge and started my company last January. From my short time to date as an entreprenur I've learnt
that my business plan has to always be visited, tweaked, changed along the way. The plan in theory is good, but according to the old saying" anything that can go wrong - will" , and I've had a number of challenges along the way.
Keeping focus though, and consistantly following up on whats taking place in my market to be one step ahead sounds easy - but add sales, accounting, strategic planning, training , shipping & logistics and the Piranhas who want to take your business before its fully off the ground and you need to be strong mentally to drive your business forward- together with Kung Fu Pandas skill!
I love what I do and though I've done a few 48 hour days to get things completed, there is no feeling like knowing it will get better and this is how microsoft , dunkin donuts , and amazon.com got started.I look at yahoo.com and I see possibilities. ..
Being an entrepreneur is not a fairy tale or for the faint - hearted. It's sifting through the advice and making decisions you take ownership for, its leading self and others towards fullfilling the goals of the company.
I've had bankers say its not possible, and comments on needing an MBA to run a business successfully.
I've also discovered I'm not alone in radical thinking,and it takes more than a dream to succeed, but it starts with a dream/idea.
As an entreprenur you're allowed to feel fear but not demonstrate you're afraid.
Mostly, though, I've come to realise that every thing I've ever read and every discussion I've ever had will help me make the decisions that will take me forward to hold me back.
I've learnt the art of listening and patience. But you must be prepared to take a chance swim in the sand and walk on the ocean.
Great topic Bill !And we need blogs like this for support!
- Posted by donna-luisa
July 30, 2008 3:06 PM
We agree fully on:
'It’s become so cheap to buy equipment, reach customers, and generate buzz on the Web, that the power of investors and venture capitalists is on the wane'
Just wondering why so many startups want to be at TechCrunch50.
It will cost at least a week of 2 people + travel, lodging and expenses.
TechCrunch50 or DEMO will bring interest from VC's, but do startups really need a VC?
Moreover do these events bring customers? paying customers?
- Posted by Engago Team
August 20, 2008 8:04 AM
Bill-
I worked for an established company a year ago & then went solo. I had some moments of laugh, few of glory & more of disappointment. Getting all the pictures to fall in place is not that easy as it sounds. The ever changing demand of customers, right people to support you with your vision, funding & brand recognition are few of prime roadblocks which I faced.
Today I stand with a fairly decent establishment of my own but like others I’ve gone through many fundamental changes. I’ve lost count on sleepless nights organizing pieces of puzzle to understand how & why Google & Yahoo! succeeded.
Today, I can relatively say that key to success is patience & honesty. Don’t think about money, it will pour, think of the people who work with you & combined intentions.
I hope to read more articles from you on this topic in forthcoming times.
- Posted by Prashant
August 21, 2008 6:20 AM