Is Your BlackBerry Lowering Your IQ?
An on-again, off-again player, I attended my first tennis clinic of the summer this last weekend. I was taken aback by the BlackBerry addled behavior which newly seems de rigeur courtside.
Between each drill at least two of the five participating players would scurry off to sidelines, rummage in a sports bag, pull out a BlackBerry and check their email. In 50% of cases this was then followed by a furtive phone call. The tennis pro rolled his eyes and muttered under his breath but seemed to have learnt to tolerate these goings-on. Along with tennis whites telephone etiquette seems to have gone out the window.
So what’s the deal here?
Have the demands of our professional lives become so extreme that it’s impossible to be “off line” for 90 minutes on a Sunday morning in August?
Or are these pressures self-inflicted? Have we become addicted to our canny communication devices because they allow us to feel indispensable? Imagining that “they need me/cannot cope without me” can be powerfully seductive.
Whatever the drivers -- whether they are external or internal -- new research points to the downside of our always-on always-in-touch culture.
Email overload can be a serious time-waster. A recent survey we conducted at the Center for Work Life Policy demonstrates that 37% of emails received by executives are either redundant or irrelevant -- and consume several hours of prime time per week.
Researchers at Kings’ College London University have found that, across the board, communication overload causes a professional’s IQ to drop 10 percentage points. It damages a worker’s performance by reducing mental sharpness. The drop in IQ is more significant among men than women.
IT consultant Linda Stone has shown how “continuous partial attention” can be seriously dysfunctional. When a professional is bombarded by multiple information streams it becomes hard to sustain focus. Innovation and creativity suffer – as does the quality of decision making. How good can your feedback be when your words of wisdom are sandwiched between intense backhand drills?
Employers are beginning to grasp the inefficiencies wrought by the contemporary glut of communication -- and some are experimenting with reining it in. BP has instituted “eMailAdvantage” -- a program that cuts back on unnecessary emails. And Intel is piloting a program that gives managers and engineers chunks of “Quiet Time” -- a period of the day when they won’t be interrupted and thus will be able to focus on work that requires concentration.
HARVARD BUSINESS ONLINE RECOMMENDS:
Managing Message Overload (HMU Article)
Coping with Too Much Communication (HMU Article)
Managing Time: Pocket Mentor Series (Paperback)
The Personal Side of Time: Mastering Work-Life Balance (Book Chapter)
Sign up for the Harvard Business Publishing Weekly Hotlist, a new weekly email roundup featuring the top highlights from HarvardBusiness.org.
- Comments (1)
- Join the Discussion
- Email/Share

Sylvia Ann Hewlett is
an
economist and the founding president of the Center for Work-Life Policy
where
she directs the “Hidden Brain Drain”—a task force of 35 global
companies
committed to fully realize female and minority talent. She also heads
up the
Gender and Policy Program at the
Comments
Interestingly, our data at Intel is close to yours - 30% of emails are reported as unnecessary, and this number is fairly constant with the years.
As to our "Quiet Time" pilot, the latest update is available on the IT at Intel blog at http://blogs.intel.com/it/2007/08/quiet_time_pilot_has_launched.html
- Posted by Nathan Zeldes
September 6, 2007 11:21 AM