The Challenge of Developing Leaders in Afghanistan
People who read this also read:
Lt. Col. Todd Henshaw, director of leadership studies at the United State Military Academy at West Point, recently spent two months in Afghanistan helping to create the National Military Academy of Afghanistan (NMAA). In the second of two posts, Henshaw explains the challenge of finding and developing leaders in Afghanistan. His comments are in quotation.
Leadership rests on the notion of authority.”Expectations for leadership in the Afghan military necessarily flow from Afghan culture, and what it means to be “in charge.”
Leaders do not shirk from challenges. Leaders whom Henshaw observed are “faced with a very difficult task involving “getting people on board,” obtaining resources in the most constrained conditions I have ever seen, and in the thick of things, amongst the violence, uncertainty, and difficulty, maintaining optimism and the necessary determination to get the job done.”
Leaders embrace challenges and shrug off the recognition. “I’ve often asked myself, ‘why are leaders so common in Afghanistan?' I think that this requires several answers. Each of these leaders [Henshaw knew] was attracted to Afghanistan by the very conditions that would make most people run from this situation. Each had an incredible passion for their purpose and their role, and each was actively developing other leaders who would eventually stand in their place. Finally, I would make the case that we have many leaders among us that, until called upon, resemble the rest of us… [T]hese leaders say that they are just doing their jobs.”
Western-style leadership has limitations. “Young Afghans also understand that western theories and concepts cannot be applied in Kabul in the same way as in Abilene. In fact, many of the questions asked by cadets in the leadership classes involve this translation of concepts within local culture.”
Leadership development must be localized. Until the Afghan professorate is ready to develop their own publications to inform the Afghan society about “Afghan Leadership,” young Afghans will rely on western thinking, albeit with a local twist. My hope would be that at least one of the cadets in the leadership major at NMAA will pursue further study, and will build the Afghan leadership press.”
Afghanistan has suffered decades’ worth of destruction at the hands of the Soviets and the Taliban. One key to helping Afghanistan join the 21st century is education. Investment in that educational process says Col. Henshaw is critical. “The young people of Afghanistan are the ones who will carry the country forward over the next century, and they also happen to be the generation whose development has been most impeded by the lack of stability in the country. It makes sense to invest in opportunities to develop the next generation of Afghan leaders by funding leadership development programs.”
Most of us will never face conditions as daunting as those in Afghanistan, but anyone who aspires to leadership can learn from young Afghanis who want to lead and the advisers who teach them. And the biggest lesson is this: leadership counts! How you demonstrate it can make the difference between success and failure.
Read Part 1: Next-generation Leadership for Afghanistan
Sign up for the Harvard Business Publishing Weekly Hotlist, a new weekly email roundup featuring the top highlights from HarvardBusiness.org.
- Comments (2)
- Join the Discussion
- Email/Share

John Baldoni is a leadership consultant, coach, and speaker. His work centers on how leaders can use their authority, communications and presence to build trust and drive results. He is the author of six books on leadership, including Lead By Example, 50 Ways Great Leaders Inspire Results. In 2007 John was named one of the world’s top 30 leadership gurus by Leadership Gurus International. For more on John and his work, visit
Comments
I am afraid that this approach simply will not do. I mean American policy in the Middle East since the 1920's has been predicated upon American interests - just as the British before them dominated the region and imposed their language and culture on their colonies. Afghanistan is not a colony, it is a sovereign nation and has its own history, culture, religions, languages and so on. That many of them do not coincide with ours does not mean that they are behind. In evolutionary terms a jellyfish in the sea might seem miles behind us in cognitive abilities - but it so happens to be better at surviving a polluted environment than the ones who made the mess in the first place, and once more, they are our cousins existing now. If you think that the US corporate model with a "local twist" will help the Afghani people survive - well that is wishful thinking, better the other way with a twist of the international. I would also like to point out that the economic needs and goals of that country are very different from Europe or the US. By the way the Soviets made exactly the same mistake about leadership; they thought Soviet Marxism with a "local twist" would work a treat!
- Posted by Stephen Pain
July 15, 2008 5:28 AM
Thank you for your thoughtful response. I would like to point out that NMAA is an Afghan institution. The U.S. military is working as an advisory capacity to help groom Afghan-developed leaders responsive to the cultural and social needs of Afghans not foreign advisors.
- Posted by John Baldoni
July 16, 2008 12:19 PM